by Barry4679 » Sat Feb 01, 2020 9:31 pm
Peke wrote: ↑Fri Jan 31, 2020 10:58 pm
we need to fetch/analyze colors of each image and then find contrast color, which hard to make and at what cost. Everything is possible, but is it worth the regression rist.
Peke, that's a rather naughty Straw Man argument .... ie. that's not the way that they would address this issue.
It is a simple UI design failing ... ie. looks pretty; doesn't work ... the fix is simple
The problem is pervasive.
Here is the top of my album grid ... albums are sorted by title, so we are looking at albums whose title are before A ... in the 1st row (!) there are three albums where the UI design has failed ... ie. the little indicator difficult to see in a busy grid. I also have many albums where the indicator is invisible.
I know that it is a little problem ... Since the indicator is often pretty much invisible, so why not delete it everywhere? ... The answer to that is that of course you wouldn't delete it, because its useful ... So ... ?
The current design is to have the arrow thing look pretty by sharing a colour tone with the album cover ... That is a UI design idea that in practice is just "form over function" ... ie. looks pretty; doesn't work
The simple fix is just to make the arrow thing a constant, easily visible contrasting colour, that is part of the skins colour pallet. .... ie. just like the colour of the selection box ... the one whose visibility is triggered by arrow-key movements, but which is AWOL when selecting by mouse, and also AWOL during scroll-to navigation .... that is the most most important issue being discussed in this thread.
[quote=Peke post_id=464958 time=1580529502 user_id=213]
we need to fetch/analyze colors of each image and then find contrast color, which hard to make and at what cost. Everything is possible, but is it worth the regression rist.
[/quote]
Peke, that's a rather naughty Straw Man argument .... ie. that's not the way that they would address this issue.
It is a simple UI design failing ... ie. looks pretty; doesn't work ... the fix is simple
The problem is pervasive. [url=https://www.dropbox.com/s/ecu1oo456mk9yfn/form%20over%20function.png?dl=0]Here is the top of my album grid[/url] ... albums are sorted by title, so we are looking at albums whose title are before A ... in the 1st row (!) there are three albums where the UI design has failed ... ie. the little indicator difficult to see in a busy grid. I also have many albums where the indicator is invisible.
I know that it is a little problem ... Since the indicator is often pretty much invisible, so why not delete it everywhere? ... The answer to that is that of course you wouldn't delete it, because its useful ... So ... ?
The current design is to have the arrow thing look pretty by sharing a colour tone with the album cover ... That is a UI design idea that in practice is just "form over function" ... ie. looks pretty; doesn't work
The simple fix is just to make the arrow thing a constant, easily visible contrasting colour, that is part of the skins colour pallet. .... ie. just like the colour of the selection box ... the one whose visibility is triggered by arrow-key movements, but which is AWOL when selecting by mouse, and also AWOL during scroll-to navigation .... that is the most most important issue being discussed in this thread.