by Giarc » Sun Dec 12, 2010 4:13 pm
I would like to comment on the MM 4.0 UI changes. In particular, I am concerned with the idea of turning the album art window into a "properties" window (
http://www.jirihajek.net/MMwiki/index.php/MM_4.0_UI ).
The Wiki shows this several different ways. The "main panel" image only shows the addition of two tabs: Selected and Now Playing. The "now playing" image also adds a bunch of metadata, and the "podcast node" image instead adds three more tabs: Art, Details, and Lyrics.
First of all, I really don't want to see a bunch of tabs and/or metadata combined with the album art. I think this will just mess up the nice clean look of the interface making it appear too "busy" (simple is beautiful).
Also, details such as the title, artist, and album are most likely already shown in the Now Playing list or the main file list anyway. If you want more details or lyrics, simply bring up the Properties dialog. That's where this information belongs, and there is lots of room for it there.
Regarding the new "Selected" and "Now Playing" tabs, I personally don't see a need for them. You can switch modes now by simply right-clicking on the art window, but I never do that anyway. I always just leave it on "Selected". If I want to see the art for what's currently playing, it's just as easy to click in the Now Playing window.
One more point - the Wiki shows the Now Playing list positioned on the right side of the screen, with the album art below it. I hope that the option will still be available to position the Now Playing list below the main file list with the album art to the right of it. That's how I like to have it. In this arrangement, the album art will display in a nicer, larger size without the tabs. Adding tabs will only serve to reduce the size of the album art.
If you agree with me on this, please chime in and let the developers know. By dropping this unnecessary change, they can get a new version released that much sooner.
I would like to comment on the MM 4.0 UI changes. In particular, I am concerned with the idea of turning the album art window into a "properties" window ( [url]http://www.jirihajek.net/MMwiki/index.php/MM_4.0_UI[/url] ).
The Wiki shows this several different ways. The "main panel" image only shows the addition of two tabs: Selected and Now Playing. The "now playing" image also adds a bunch of metadata, and the "podcast node" image instead adds three more tabs: Art, Details, and Lyrics.
First of all, I really don't want to see a bunch of tabs and/or metadata combined with the album art. I think this will just mess up the nice clean look of the interface making it appear too "busy" (simple is beautiful).
Also, details such as the title, artist, and album are most likely already shown in the Now Playing list or the main file list anyway. If you want more details or lyrics, simply bring up the Properties dialog. That's where this information belongs, and there is lots of room for it there.
Regarding the new "Selected" and "Now Playing" tabs, I personally don't see a need for them. You can switch modes now by simply right-clicking on the art window, but I never do that anyway. I always just leave it on "Selected". If I want to see the art for what's currently playing, it's just as easy to click in the Now Playing window.
One more point - the Wiki shows the Now Playing list positioned on the right side of the screen, with the album art below it. I hope that the option will still be available to position the Now Playing list below the main file list with the album art to the right of it. That's how I like to have it. In this arrangement, the album art will display in a nicer, larger size without the tabs. Adding tabs will only serve to reduce the size of the album art.
If you agree with me on this, please chime in and let the developers know. By dropping this unnecessary change, they can get a new version released that much sooner.