by Big_Berny » Fri Dec 28, 2007 3:57 pm
I wouldn't do trackgain, because it's bad on some albums. Albumgain is in almost all cases better.
Example: Some volume differences on different tracks of a CD are intended and with trackgain you just remove them. A even worse effect appears if tracks are continuously or when a song is splitted into multiple parts (classical). Then you will hear a change in volume if one trackvolume got raised (because it has a lot silent parts) and the other hasn't.
I do it like this: I use MP3Gain to albumgain all the songs. Then I let analyze them in MediaMonkey. Since mediamonkey syncs the trackgain to the ipod I can now choose between track- and albumgain when using my ipod. With SoundCheck disabled I've album-gain and when I enable SoundCheck I've trackgain.
Big_Berny
I wouldn't do trackgain, because it's bad on some albums. Albumgain is in almost all cases better.
Example: Some volume differences on different tracks of a CD are intended and with trackgain you just remove them. A even worse effect appears if tracks are continuously or when a song is splitted into multiple parts (classical). Then you will hear a change in volume if one trackvolume got raised (because it has a lot silent parts) and the other hasn't.
I do it like this: I use MP3Gain to albumgain all the songs. Then I let analyze them in MediaMonkey. Since mediamonkey syncs the trackgain to the ipod I can now choose between track- and albumgain when using my ipod. With SoundCheck disabled I've album-gain and when I enable SoundCheck I've trackgain.
Big_Berny