Why? because although the app offers most of what I need, I've found that it is not as reliable as I'd like. Specifically, after working in it for a couple of hours and making a bunch of changes to numerous song tags/filenames, the app crashed (I received a message about Access not being able to update something or other). Granted, this only happened once, however, the repercussion was that much of my work was lost (even though I _had_ selected the option to 'Write ID3 tags after edit song properties', and rescanned the path to my music files).
My hypothesis is that although the app 'says' that ID3 tags are updated immediately after editing, they aren't always updated properly (it seems to me that much of the ID3 data was lost for songs that had tags which I had edited, rather than for songs to which I'd added new tags. also, songs in which I had changed the tags _and_ filename seemed to experience greater data loss).
I experienced a number of other quirks that may be of interest to the developer(s):
-In-table editing: clicking a field to edit it forces the user to wait ~1s before the field becomes editable (on a P500). This is far too slow.
-In-table editing: 'delete' button doesn't work--user must advance and use 'backspace' instead
-Tag editing doesn't always seem to result in updates to Tags. E.g. I change Artist: 'abba' to 'Abba' but immediately after I make the change, the ID3 text reverts to its previous format
-Edits to the 'Genre' fields seem to sometimes result in the Tag appearing twice in other apps (e.g. instead of 'Rock', 'Rock, Rock' appears in Helium). Not sure if this is a bug in Helium or Song-DB.
-The ID3V2 fields are nice, but it seems that other than the basic information that is included in a V1 Tag, NONE of the fields are visible in other music applications! I would have hoped that at least the Tempo, Mood, Occasion, Preference fields could be read by MusicMatch or other apps that support MusicMatch tags, so that I'm not permanently locked into using Song-DB!!
I would also offer a couple of feature improvements:
-Would be nice to be able to configure which columns are shown (e.g. rather than show 'path', I would like to see a column for 'filename' so that the paths to my files don't take up the entire screen)
-Would be very useful to have a place to dock the 'Song Properties' dialog for those occasions when the user is updating their DB (so that they don't have to go through the step of opening the dialog box).
-Would be amazingly useful to help the user get more of the info that they're looking for from freedb when clicking 'details' from the 'song properties' dialog. e.g. if I have a song by Rolling Stones entitled 19th Nervous Breakdown, and I wanted to find out the Album and Year of the song, clicking 'Details' returns a bunch of Albums that _don't_ include the song!! If it were possible to use both the Artist _and_ Track Title fields to narrow the search, then the user would get a much more refined/useful search result.
All in all--this looks to be really promising, but still rough around the edges. I really look forward to trying out the next version of the app.